Peter Robinson challenges Mark Krikorian to explain why America -- a nation of immigrants -- should now adopt anti-immigration policies.
Krikorian responds by asserting that mass immigration is fundamentally incompatible with a modern society, that it causes a serious erosion of sovereignty, and that it creates a net economic burden on the government.
Finally, he details the dangers of transnationalism and multiculturalism that are inherent in immigration today and gives his prescription for solving the problem.
Bio
Mark Krikorian
Mark Krikorian is the executive director of the Center for Immigration Studies, a think-tank in Washington, D.C. that promotes stricter immigration standards and enforcement. Also, Krikorian is a regular contributor to the conservative publication National Review as well as a regular participant at National Review Online's "The Corner".
He is author of The New Case Against Immigration, Both Legal and Illegal, published in 2008.
Peter Robinson
Peter M. Robinson is a research fellow at the Hoover Institution, where he writes about business and politics, edits the Hoover Institution's quarterly journal, the Hoover Digest, and hosts Hoover's television program, "Uncommon Knowledge."
Robinson is also the author of three books: How Ronald Reagan Changed My Life; It's My Party: A Republican's Messy Love Affair with the GOP; and the best-selling business book Snapshots from Hell: The Making of an MBA.
How does every problem get twisted into a left vs. right antagonism? Who cares about your petty party loyalties?
There were people espousing these same insular nationalist ideals a century ago, when the Irish were coming to America en masse (oh no!).
It's childish, and frankly a little dangerous. The real issue here is the pervasiveness of entitlement programs.
If we had anything resembling a free society and market, those who came to our country and were successful would have a financial incentive to stay, while those who were not would have a reason to leave. We would not have to fund an immigration patrol and talk about locking down our borders.
turbobrain: well, yeah, illegal immigration is a problem. But this guy wants to go even further and stop, or at least limit, legal immigration. As for Democrats and their massive spending, I don't think Republicans show much more restraint in that area, and at least Democrats try to fund their spending with tax revenue rather than borrowing us into catastrophic debt with no concern as to how we might eventually pay it back.
Immigration is a huge problem in the US precisely because of economic problems we are facing. I suspect that if the US was doing well, this wouldn't be much of an issue. Illegal immigration simply must be stopped. Perhaps it would be best if we stopped the war on drugs and funded a "war" on illegal immigration. Unless of course, Americans are willing to reform welfare (aka. get rid of it). Democrats are their massive spending are what is wrong with this country. But the immigrants love it. Wake up America, we are imploding from the inside.
I love how the number one negative consequence of immigration is that states begin to trend Democratic. God forbid! Seems like evidence that Republicans are still unaware they are imploding from the inside. It's hard not to read a bit of xenophobia into this argument, even though I believe that is unintended.