FORA.tv

The Smart Network

Mormonism & American Politics: Noah Feldman

Other
Rate It
16,210 Views
  • Info
  • Bio
  • Full Program
  • Highlights
  • Transcript
  • Download
  • More
kaiwai Avatar
kaiwai
Posts: 1
Posted: 01.15.08, 02:52 AM
I'd love to watch this video but the bandwidth is so crappy - someone do something about it; it really spoils the video.
Permalink
observer Avatar
observer
Posts: 1
Posted: 02.03.08, 02:09 PM
False Tenant that a candidates religion should not matter
Noah Feldman tries to convince his audience that the religion of a presidential candidate should not matter to voters. This is ridiculous. A person's religious views says everything about a candidate. The fact that a man can believe what the mormon church teaches makes him a scary person to hold the office of President of the United States. This is not bigoty. This is discernment, discretion, and sound judgement.
Permalink
birdman Avatar
birdman
Posts: 1
Posted: 04.06.08, 02:41 PM
Could you clarify what makes belief in Mormon doctrine a disqualifying attribute for President? Are other Christian beliefs -- Adam & Eve, virgin birth, resurrection, atonement (and for the Catholics, transubstantiation) any less remarkable or fantastical, other than that they carry the patina of having been believed for several thousand years.

Is the argument that all religious belief is disqualifying, or only Mormon religious belief?

Finally, your assertion may not be bigoted, but absent any carefully reasoned line of argument or a clearly delineated martialing of evidence to support it, one could be excused for interpreting it as such.
Permalink
Erasmus Avatar
Erasmus
Posts: 0
Posted: 08.23.08, 09:36 AM
It's not ridiculous, and I think it's an excellent ideal, but unfortunately it can't be entirely divorced from issues that "should" matter. In the same way, contra the quotation early in the address, a candicate's views on "geometry," science more broadly, do matter because of the implications of scientific advancement.
Permalink
niatek Avatar
niatek
Posts: 5
Posted: 01.03.09, 09:56 PM
Noah Feldman ROCKS!!! ...and talk about his bio...WOW great accolades! I greatly enjoyed his thoughts and theories on the topic! I gotta go read his books! =)
Permalink
anselmiano Avatar
anselmiano
Posts: 6
Posted: 09.22.09, 07:58 PM
Noah poses a fallacious "either or" causation for Mormon secrecy: persecution or bigotry, on the part of its detractors. There's at least one other cause that is obvious to those who are acquainted with the goings on of the Mormon church, namely the desire to further your ends and your own vested interests at the expense of the truth. One instance of this is the "faith promoting" approach to church history advanced by church leaders, which seeks to conceal the less flattering (or downright shameful) episodes or aspects of the mormon experience in order to present an image attractive to prospective converts or geared to membership retention. Is it persecution for a critic to point out, for instance, that the Egyptian papiry Joseph Smith claimed to translate into the Book of Abraham (canonized as Mormon scripture) in the 1840s, once translated by egyptologists in the 1960s have nothing to do with Abraham but are rather common funeral prayers from the Book of the Dead? Mormons certainly call it persecution when this, as well as other fraudulent teachings of theirs, are exposed. On a more practical level, now that the religious right is preponderantly composed of protestant evangelicals who with some substance, as Jan Shipps will attest to, don't regard Mormon as Christians, is it possible that Joseph Smith having claimed that God revealed to him that all those protestant churches taught false doctrines and were "an abomination" in the sight of God, could be coming back to haunt our contemporary Mormon politician? Is that persecution or bigotry against Mormons? ... or just reaping what they sowed...
Permalink
Please log in or register to post a comment.
Advertisement

Related Programs

Bangladesh’s Swing to Radicalism Bangladesh’s Swing to Radicalism
01:42:03 min | 4,880 Views
Politics and Religious Identity Politics and Religious Identity
01:29:28 min | 5,562 Views
A Discussion on Sacred Water A Discussion on Sacred Water
00:34:36 min | 2,798 Views
Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court Inside the Secret World of the Supreme Court
00:28:34 min | 6,762 Views
Shmuel Bar: The Strategy of the Jihadi Movement Shmuel Bar: The Strategy of the Jihadi Movement
00:59:14 min | 3,134 Views

Browse Programs by Tag

Arts Books Climate Change Computing Conflict Credit Crunch Defense Democratization Economic Policy Education Election 2008 Emerging Markets Energy Entertainment Entrepreneurship Environment Film Food Globalization Health & Wellness Healthcare History Internet Investing Law Medicine Music Muslim World Natural Sciences New Media Personal Technology Philanthropy Religion Social Issues Social Sciences Sustainability Terrorism The Bailout U.S. Foreign Policy White House 2009

Advertisement