The Center for American Progress hosts The Great Debate: What is Net Neutrality? on The Communicators Series. Vinton G. Cerf, Google, V.P. & Chief Internet Evangelist and Dave Farber, Carnegie Mellon University, Distinguished Career Professor of Computer Science and Public Policy debate the issue of net neutrality. The Communicators is a new C-SPAN series that focuses on the people and events that shape telecommunications policy.
Bio
Vinton G. Cerf
Vint Cerf is a living legend in the tech world. In 2004, with Robert Kahn, he received the Alan M. Turing Award, the highest professional honor in computing, in recognition of their visionary
work and leadership in the development of the Internet. Other honors, again with Robert Kahn, include the US National Medal of Technology, the Japan Prize, and the Presidential Medal of
Freedom. He was the founding president of the Internet Society and served as chairman of the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers from 2000 to 2007.
Before joining Google in 2005, Cerf was a senior vice presidentat MCI and a vice president of the Corporation for National Research Initiatives. He began his career at IBM and UCLA. He joined the faculty of Stanford University where he co-designed the TCP/IP protocols and network architecture of the Internet. From 1976 to 1982, he was a principal scientist at DARPA, where he managed the Internet and packet communications research programs. He joined MCI in 1982, where he helped develop the commercial MCI Mail service. Cerf has been elected a member of the National Academy of Engineering and a fellow of the IEEE, the American Association for the Advancement of Science, the American Academy of Arts and Sciences, and the International
Engineering Consortium.
David J. Farber
David J. Farber is a professor of Computer Science, noted for his major contributions to programming languages and computer networking. He is currently Distinguished Career Professor of Computer Science and Public Policy at the School of Computer Science at Carnegie Mellon University.
Dr. Farber is an IEEE Fellow, ACM Fellow, and recipient of the 1995 SIGCOMM Award for life-long contributions to computer communications. He has served on the board of directors of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the Electronic Privacy Information Center advisory board, the Board of Trustees of the Internet Society, and as a member of the Presidential Advisory Committee on High Performance Computing and Communications, Information Technology and Next Generation Internet. He runs a huge (25,000+ member) mail list called Interesting-People.
I thought Prof. Farber’s reticence towards government regulation was very interesting. We are accustomed to thinking of regulation as a positive force designed to protect the interests of consumers and to promote fair competition. Yet Prof. Farber strongly believes that excessive government intervention will impede the growth and development of technology.
Another interesting comment by Prof. Farber was his statement that in the cable industry, carriers often pay for content. This opens up the possibility that major internet companies could “turn the tables†on ISPs: Rather than paying ISPs to deliver their content, as some ISPs have been demanding, internet companies could instead charge ISPs for the right to carry their content.
Both speakers offer pros and cons for both the further regulation and de-regulation of the state of the internet. Farber and Cerf both have had milestone careers in the creation and advancement of the internet. Vint Cerf offers a convincing argument to keep the internet open, however, one must question if he has any special interest in the net neutrality debate considering he is the vice president for google.